Can Take­da ac­tu­al­ly close its $65B deal to buy Shire? Maybe, but an­a­lysts aren't sure they should

Take­da has upped its of­fer to buy Shire $SH­PG for a mix of stock and cash worth close to $65 bil­lion, which is good enough for the Lex­ing­ton, MA-based biotech to ex­tend the dead­line on their talks to May 8 af­ter de­ter­min­ing they were close to fi­nal­iz­ing a pact.

Late Tues­day Shire re­port­ed that Take­da had upped its bid to £27.26 in new Take­da shares and £21.75 in cash, com­ing to £49 a share. That rings up at 0.839 new Take­da shares and $30.33 for each Shire share — or close to $65 bil­lion, with Take­da tack­ing about $2.5 bil­lion on its pre­vi­ous of­fer.

In a state­ment, Shire not­ed that its board said they would rec­om­mend the of­fer, pro­vid­ed they can get through some re­main­ing hur­dles, in­clud­ing their due dili­gence work.

But it’s not a done deal yet, and there are con­sid­er­able doubts whether it’s in Take­da’s best in­ter­est — or Shire’s — to com­plete the process. Those doubts were height­ened af­ter in­vestors drove Take­da’s shares down 7% in the wake of the agree­ment, leav­ing the stock down about 20% since talks were dis­closed — hard­ly a ring­ing en­dorse­ment.

Will a 44% cash/56% eq­ui­ty deal suf­fi­cient­ly en­tice Shire’s grum­bling share­hold­ers? Maybe, says Jef­feries an­a­lyst David Stein­berg. He not­ed:

While this of­fer rep­re­sents a sol­id im­prove­ment over Take­da’s third bid (38% cash), we still won­der if it is enough to sat­is­fy SH­PG share­hold­ers, who would still bear some not in­signif­i­cant risk go­ing for­ward as ~50% own­ers of New­Co. Of in­ter­est, SH­PG now seems to be en­gag­ing – and step­ping away from pri­or com­men­tary that a sim­i­lar (4% low­er) bid “sig­nif­i­cant­ly un­der­val­ues the com­pa­ny”. And we be­lieve that the lat­est of­fer of ~$205/ADR by Take­da will be con­sid­ered at­trac­tive to many SH­PG share­hold­ers, par­tic­u­lar­ly if it has a greater com­po­nent of cash vs stock.

Bern­stein’s Ron­ny Gal looked at the risks to the deal and still es­ti­mat­ed a like­ly com­ple­tion at 80% to 90%, giv­en a will­ing buy­er and a will­ing sell­er at the ta­ble. But he’s not so sure that Take­da’s in­vestors are on board.

The risk to the deal is un­like­ly in our view to come from Shire share­hold­ers or an­ti-trust au­thor­i­ties. How­ev­er, Take­da share­hold­ers (and po­ten­tial­ly the board) may prove re­sis­tant giv­en the stock de­cline.

Nei­ther Gal nor Stein­berg think a hos­tile bid­der is like­ly to come along at the last minute, giv­en all the at­ten­tion to this deal as it brewed, though the pos­si­bil­i­ty re­mains. Any­body who has thought of do­ing it has prob­a­bly de­cid­ed to stay out of it. (GSK chief Em­ma Walm­s­ley al­so got her chance to­day to brush off the ques­tion, rul­ing out a bid no one thought pos­si­ble in any case.) And Al­ler­gan CEO Brent Saun­ders isn’t like­ly to change his mind af­ter get­ting slapped down quick for men­tion­ing an in­ter­est.

This is what Take­da CEO Christophe We­ber has been work­ing to­wards since he was named to the top job — aim­ing at build­ing a glob­al op­er­a­tor with roots in Japan — and in­vestors are clear­ly fret­ting about the re­al­i­ty of it. With a lit­tle more than $4 bil­lion in cash on hand, the idea of the small­er Take­da buy­ing up Shire and leav­ing Shire in­vestors with half of the stock in the post-merg­er bio­phar­ma com­pa­ny is not sit­ting well with every­one.

Some an­a­lysts have been won­der­ing why Take­da would pay a pre­mi­um for a com­pa­ny that is fac­ing stiff head­winds on key fran­chis­es as Roche ad­vances Hem­li­bra for he­mo­phil­ia and its AD­HD group con­fronts the even­tu­al loss of con­trol over their Vy­vanse IP.

We­ber, though, shows no signs of wa­ver­ing in his de­ter­mi­na­tion to com­plete this deal.

There are a few key is­sues that will need to be com­plet­ed:

— Agree­ment of cer­tain oth­er (un­spec­i­fied) terms of the re­vised pro­pos­al.
— Sat­is­fac­to­ry com­ple­tion of a con­fir­ma­to­ry due dili­gence re­view by Take­da.
— The unan­i­mous and un­con­di­tion­al rec­om­men­da­tion of the board of Shire.
— And fi­nal ap­proval by the board of Take­da.

Take­da fol­lowed with a re­lease of its own stat­ing:

Take­da and its Board have re­mained dis­ci­plined with re­spect to the terms of the Re­vised Pro­pos­al and Take­da in­tends to main­tain its well-es­tab­lished div­i­dend pol­i­cy and in­vest­ment grade cred­it rat­ing.

A matchup with Shire would give Take­da a huge Boston/Cam­bridge re­search group — even af­ter some pre­sumed deep cuts in per­son­nel — ex­pand­ing on Shire’s move to con­cen­trate its forces in Lex­ing­ton and Cam­bridge fol­low­ing its Bax­al­ta buy­out. Take­da has al­so been gath­er­ing its R&D forces in the big Boston hub. A deal would al­so like­ly sig­nal a fur­ther wrench­ing re­or­ga­ni­za­tion for lo­cal Shire staffers, who have been through re­peat­ed re­vamp­ing un­der CEO Flem­ming Orn­skov while Take­da has spent much of the past two years re­struc­tur­ing and cut­ting re­search.

A mega-merg­er like this, dwarf­ing a se­ries of ac­qui­si­tions in Q1, would al­so leave bio­phar­ma in­vestors hunt­ing for the next big tar­get, with 2018 shap­ing up as a big year for buy­outs.


Im­age: Christophe We­ber, pres­i­dent and chief ex­ec­u­tive of­fi­cer of Take­da Get­ty

The DCT-OS: A Tech­nol­o­gy-first Op­er­at­ing Sys­tem - En­abling Clin­i­cal Tri­als

As technology-enabled clinical research becomes the new normal, an integrated decentralized clinical trial operating system can ensure quality, deliver consistency and improve the patient experience.

The increasing availability of COVID-19 vaccines has many of us looking forward to a time when everyday things return to a state of normal. Schools and teachers are returning to classrooms, offices and small businesses are reopening, and there’s a palpable sense of optimism that the often-awkward adjustments we’ve all made personally and professionally in the last year are behind us, never to return. In the world of clinical research, however, some pandemic-necessitated adjustments are proving to be more than emergency stopgap measures to ensure trial continuity — and numerous decentralized clinical trial (DCT) tools and methodologies employed within the last year are likely here to stay as part of biopharma’s new normal.

'Chang­ing the whole game of drug dis­cov­ery': Leg­endary R&D vet Roger Perl­mut­ter leaps back in­to work as a biotech CEO

Roger Perlmutter needs no introduction to anyone remotely involved in biopharma. As the R&D chief first at Amgen and then Merck, he’s built a stellar reputation and a prolific career steering new drugs toward the market for everything from cancer to infectious diseases.

But for years, he’s also held a less known title: science partner at The Column Group, where he’s regularly consulted about the various ideas the VCs had for new startups.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 104,600+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

FDA ex­tends re­search agree­ment with MIT-li­censed or­gan-on-chip sys­tems

The FDA on Wednesday extended its four-year agreement with CN Bio, a developer of single- and multi-organ-on-chip systems used for drug discovery, for another three years.

CN Bio said the scope of the research performed by the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research has expanded to include the exploration of the company’s lung-on-a-chip system to help with the agency’s evaluation of inhaled drugs, in addition to the agency’s work on its liver model.

Endpoints Premium

Premium subscription required

Unlock this article along with other benefits by subscribing to one of our paid plans.

In quest to meet user fee goals, FDA’s per­for­mance con­tin­ues down­ward trend

A recent update to the FDA’s running tally of how it’s meeting its user fee-related performance goals during the pandemic shows an agency that is not out of the woods yet.

The latest numbers reveal that for a second straight quarter in 2021, the FDA has met its user fee goal dates for 93% of original new drug applications, which compares with 94% and 98% for the previous two quarters in 2020, respectively.

Endpoints Premium

Premium subscription required

Unlock this article along with other benefits by subscribing to one of our paid plans.

UP­DAT­ED: Pfiz­er hits the brakes on their piv­otal tri­al for a BC­MA/CD3 bis­pe­cif­ic on safe­ty con­cerns while FDA road­block is hold­ing up Duchenne MD PhI­II

Pfizer’s ambitious plan to take a Phase II study of its BCMA CD3-targeted bispecific antibody elranatamab (PF-06863135) and run it through to an accelerated approval has derailed.

The pharma giant said in a release this morning that they have halted enrollment for their MagnetisMM-3 study after researchers tracked three cases of peripheral neuropathy in the ongoing Phase I. They are now sharing info with the FDA as they explore the red safety flag.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 104,600+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Joe Wiley, Amryt CEO

A biotech with a yen for pricey rare dis­ease drugs — and bar­gain base­ment shop­ping — adopts an­oth­er or­phan in lat­est M&A pact

After making it through a long, painful haul to get past a CRL and on to an FDA approval last summer, little Chiasma has found a buyer.

Amryt $AMYT, a company known for its appetite for acquiring expensive drugs for rare diseases at bargain prices, snagged Chiasma and its acromegaly drug Mycapssa (octreotide) capsules in an all-stock deal — with an exchange of 0.396 shares of Amryt for every share of Chiasma.

Thomas Schall, ChemoCentryx CEO (file photo)

Chemo­Cen­tryx plunges as FDA rais­es ques­tions about rare dis­ease drug ahead of ad­comm

ChemoCentryx’s stock price on Wednesday was cut in half by the release of FDA briefing documents ahead of a Thursday adcomm, raising questions on the company’s clinical data to support avacopan as a treatment for adults with a rare and serious disease known as anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibody (ANCA)-vasculitis.

ANCA-associated vasculitides (AAV) affect small to medium-size blood vessels that can be fatal in less than a year if left untreated, according to FDA. Only Roche’s Rituxan is currently FDA-approved for the treatment of AAV, while glucocorticoids are approved for the broader indication of vasculitis.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 104,600+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Al­ta­sciences, true to its word, ex­pands its foot­print with ac­qui­si­tion of Penn­syl­va­nia CRO

A Canadian CDMO with roots in Seattle is coming to the east coast.

Altasciences announced the acquisition of Calvert Laboratories Wednesday, a preclinical CRO in Pennsylvania. The move will complement Altasciences’ Seattle-area operations.

Headquartered in Laval, Canada, Altasciences operates six facilities that run the gamut on early drug development: preclinical safety testing, clinical pharmacology, bioanalytical, CRO services, and even CDMO capacity. Novo Holdings scooped them up in February with the goal of courting small and medium-sized biopharma clients. CEO Chris Perkin said back in February that the move would help the company foster its ambitious growth plan, and this acquisition and the presence it brings to the east coast is evidence.

Re­gen­eron’s gold­en goose Eylea may stave off biosim­i­lar com­pe­ti­tion un­til 2024 or be­yond

Almost 10 years have passed since its first FDA approval and Regeneron’s macular degeneration injection Eylea continues to pile up sales to the tune of about $5 billion per year, or more than half of Regeneron’s annual revenues.

Those billions are not expected to go anywhere anytime soon thanks to competition, even as Novartis subsidiary Sandoz announced Monday that it’s beginning a Phase III trial for an Eylea biosimilar in 460 patients across 20 countries.