Updated: FDA calls for noninferiority trials for antibacterials, thanks to new drugs for resistant infections
The FDA on Monday said it updated its recommendations for the clinical development of new antibacterial drugs, and thanks to a new clutch of drugs, sponsors will have to conduct noninferiority trials that include subjects with infections caused by certain drug-resistant organisms because an effective active control can be provided.
The guidance, which has since been released, builds on a 2017 document and specifies what noninferiority trial designs may be used “with a wider NI margin,” including cases in which the trial population is enriched for subjects with infections caused by certain drug-resistant organisms, FDA said.
The federal agency said in the guidance that the active comparator used to show noninferiority should be effective for the population enrolled in the clinical trial, further stating that the primary analysis should exclude subjects with baseline pathogens resistant to the control.
“A randomized trial design is needed because both comparative safety and efficacy evaluations can be performed. The randomized clinical trial data can be supported by confirmatory evidence from nonclinical studies demonstrating the activity of the investigational drug against resistant phenotypes,” the guidance went on to say.
When drafting the guidance, an FDA spokesperson told Endpoints News that FDA was considering recently approved beta-lactam/beta-lactamase inhibitor combinations that showed extended activity against drug-resistant organisms, such as those that produce carbapenemases.
Since 2017, about 12 new drugs won approval in this space, showing activity against treatment-resistant organisms — including drugs like TB Alliance’s pretomanid, which got the thumbs up from the federal regulator for treatment-resistant tuberculosis approved back in 2019. Others include Achaogen’s plazomicin, now known as Zemdri, for complicated urinary tract infections in 2018 and Novartis spinoff Nabriva’s lefamulin for pneumonia.
Yet as NIH researchers added in an article they wrote in late 2019, that number of drugs is not enough for the space.
The 2017-era guidance originally focused on flexibility, with the agency saying that “it is appropriate to exercise the broadest flexibility in applying the statutory standards, while preserving appropriate guarantees for safety and effectiveness.” It added that it recognized that physicians and patients are “generally willing to accept greater risks or side effects from drugs that treat life-threatening and severely-debilitating illnesses, than they would accept from drugs that treat less serious illnesses.”