Af­ter kick­back from the FDA, Bris­tol-My­ers yanks its Op­di­vo/Yer­voy BLA for high TMB ap­proach to lung can­cer

Bris­tol-My­ers Squibb has had a hard time win­ning an­a­lysts over to its strat­e­gy for carv­ing out a high­er mar­ket share for its check­point com­bo in non-small cell lung can­cer. And now you can add the FDA to the list of skep­tics re­quir­ing more da­ta to con­vince them.

In their Q4 re­lease Thurs­day morn­ing Bris­tol-My­ers Squibb says it is yank­ing its BLA for Op­di­vo com­bined with Yer­voy for front­line NSCLC cas­es with high tu­mor mu­ta­tion­al bur­den — or TMB — af­ter talks with the agency con­vinced them they need­ed more da­ta to high­light the con­nec­tion be­tween TMB and PD-L1.

Their state­ment:

This analy­sis will re­quire avail­abil­i­ty of the fi­nal da­ta from Check­mate -227, Part 1a (Op­di­vo plus low-dose Yer­voy or Op­di­vo monother­a­py ver­sus chemother­a­py in pa­tients whose tu­mors ex­press PD-L1), which the com­pa­ny an­tic­i­pates will be avail­able in the first-half of 2019. Since these da­ta from Check­mate -227, Part 1a, will not be avail­able with­in the re­view cy­cle of the cur­rent ap­pli­ca­tion the com­pa­ny de­cid­ed to with­draw.

Bris­tol-My­ers’ stock took a 2.4% hit in trad­ing ahead of the open­ing bell.

Long­time ob­servers have been puz­zling out the whole TMB ap­proach, which As­traZeneca has al­so been turn­ing to in the wake of its own PD-L1/CT­LA-4 set­backs with Imfinzi and treme­li­mum­ab. Bris­tol-My­ers re­designed its crit­i­cal late-stage tri­al to shift to TMB, and it has not played out in their fa­vor — so far.

Af­ter Mer­ck seized the lead in lung can­cer with its su­pe­ri­or Keytru­da/chemo com­bo, Bris­tol-My­ers’ team led by R&D chief Tom Lynch has been strug­gling to make a come­back. Typ­i­cal­ly, the FDA has been wide open — at least in re­cent years — to ac­cel­er­at­ed ap­provals for can­cer drugs. In this case, Bris­tol-My­ers found that the bar has been raised as physi­cians em­ploy a grow­ing num­ber of PD-1/L1s in their prac­tice.

Cred­it Su­isse’s bio­phar­ma team took at look at the news and con­clud­ed that, on bal­ance, Bris­tol-My­ers’ move rais­es fresh con­cerns.

We did not think an ap­proval for that fil­ing would have made much of a near-term com­mer­cial im­pact any­way, but it does raise new ques­tions on the com­pa­ny’s over­all strat­e­gy and ap­proach in 1L NSCLC.

In an up­date last Oc­to­ber, re­searchers for Bris­tol-My­ers not­ed that the haz­ard ra­tio for their com­bo was roughy iden­ti­cal for high and low TMB groups get­ting the com­bo, but the over­all sur­vival rate was 23 months for high TMB pa­tients at 16.7 months in a chemo arm with high TMB. There was al­so a dif­fer­ence of a few months for the low TMB group.

The set­back comes just weeks af­ter Bris­tol-My­ers an­nounced its plan to ac­quire Cel­gene for $74 bil­lion. And to­day there was a big fo­cus on the top late-stage drugs they will gain from Cel­gene: Ozan­i­mod, with a Q1 re­fil­ing plan; the CAR-T Liso-cel (JCAR017 from the Juno buy­out), with an H2 2019 fil­ing plan; and the an­ti-BC­MA CAR-T bb2121 part­nered with blue­bird, fil­ing in H1 2020. All that has to counter ques­tions re­volv­ing around the IP for Revlim­id.

The lat­est prob­lem with the Op­di­vo fran­chise over­shad­owed the com­pa­ny’s Q4 and 2018 fi­nan­cial re­port, which high­light­ed a 10% hike in sales. Op­di­vo it­self earned $6.7 bil­lion last year, up from just un­der $5 bil­lion in 2017. The rest of the ap­proved slate pf PD-1/L1s has been strug­gling to get in­to the same league with Mer­ck and Bris­tol-My­ers Squibb.


Im­age: Thomas Lynch at BIO 2018. ROB TAN­NEN­BAUM for END­POINTS NEWS

Tal Zaks, Moderna CMO (Moderna via YouTube)

UP­DAT­ED: NI­AID and Mod­er­na spell out a 'ro­bust' im­mune re­sponse in PhI coro­n­avirus vac­cine test — but big ques­tions re­main to be an­swered

The NIAID and Moderna have spelled out positive Phase I safety and efficacy data for their Covid-19 vaccine mRNA-1273 — highlighting the first full, clear sketch of evidence that back-to-back jabs at the dose selected for Phase III routinely produced a swarm of antibodies to the virus that exceeded levels seen in convalescent patients — typically in multiples indicating a protective response.

Moderna execs say plainly that this first stage of research produced exactly the kind of efficacy they hoped to see in humans, with a manageable safety profile.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 85,300+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Trans­port Sim­u­la­tion Test­ing for Your Ther­a­py is the Best Way to As­sure FDA Ex­pe­dit­ed Pro­gram Ap­proval

Modality Solutions is an ISO:9001-registered biopharmaceutical cold chain engineering firm with unique transport simulation capabilities that support accelerated regulatory approval for biologics and advanced therapeutic medicinal products (ATMP). Our expertise combines traditional validation engineering approaches with regulatory knowledge into a methodology tailored for the life sciences industry. We provide insight and execution for the challenges faced in your cold chain logistics network.

Tillman Gerngross, Adagio Therapeutics CEO

An­ti­body leg­end Till­man Gern­gross is el­bow­ing his way in­to the Covid-19 R&D cru­sade: 'I don’t see this end­ing any­time soon'

One of the most influential — and outspoken — scientists at work in the field of antibody discovery is jumping into the frenzied race to create new therapeutics to treat and prevent Covid-19. And he’s operating with the conviction that the current outbreak now once again spreading like wildfire will create plenty of demand for what he has in mind.

Dartmouth professor and Adimab CEO Tillman Gerngross tells me he’s raised $50 million from a group of close VCs to spin out a new company — Adagio Therapeutics — with a full C-suite team assembled to hire up a staff and keep rolling toward the clinic.

Endpoints Premium

Premium subscription required

Unlock this article along with other benefits by subscribing to one of our paid plans.

Full Bril­in­ta study re­sults show the blood thin­ner re­duces rate of sec­ondary stroke

AstraZeneca once projected its Brilinta drug to peak at $3.5 billion in sales, and though the blood thinner never reached that lofty goal, it received the latest positive signs in a string of recent good news.

The pharma released full details from its THALES study Thursday morning, which measured the effects of Brilinta and aspirin against aspirin alone in treating patients who had an acute ischemic stroke or transient ischemic attack. When taken twice daily with once-a-day aspirin for 30 days, the Brilinta combo reduced the risk of stroke and death by 17 percent, meeting the primary endpoint of the study.

Norbert Bischofberger, Kronos CEO

Gilead­'s ex-R&D chief Bischof­berg­er heads back to the biotech gi­ant to pick up a pair of late-stage drugs that had been put aside

Norbert Bischofberger knows entospletinib well.

Back during his long, blockbuster run as head of R&D at Gilead, researchers had once held some high hopes for this drug. But to make it work, he and the team felt it would need a new companion diagnostic to identify patients. There was talk of a combo approach to give it more punch. But the market was small, making them wonder if it would be worth going through a lengthy development cycle to get it through a pivotal.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 85,300+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Source: Shutterstock

Who are the women blaz­ing trails in bio­phar­ma R&D and lead­ing the fight against Covid-19? Nom­i­nate them for End­points' spe­cial re­port

One of the many inequalities the pandemic has laid bare is the gender imbalance in biomedical research. A paper examining Covid-19 research authorship wondered out loud: Where are the women?

It’s a question that echoes beyond our current times. In the biopharma world, not only are women under-represented in R&D roles (particularly at higher levels), their achievements and talents could also be undermined by stereotypes and norms of leadership styles. The problem is even more dire for women of color.

Mer­ck KGaA takes its I/O op­tion on F-star Ther­a­peu­tics; Nephron spends $215M, eye­ing spot in Covid-19 vac­cine chain

→Merck KGaA has taken an early option on an immuno-oncology program developed at F-star Therapeutics. This is their second option in the collaboration. And they added a pair of preclinical discovery programs to the alliance as well.

Any biotech going public these days wouldn’t feel right if they didn’t upsize the offering. And that’s just what Phase I biotech Pandion Therapeutics did. The autoimmune company is now selling 7 million shares, a 1.5 million share bump, for $16 to $18 a share.

The $1B Mer­ck-Bay­er drug that di­vid­ed car­di­ol­o­gists in March gets pri­or­i­ty re­view

Three months after Merck published in the New England Journal of Medicine data that left doctors and investors divided over just how well its experimental heart drug worked, the FDA has handed that drug priority review. A decision is now due by January 20, 2021.

Merck first announced the drug, known as vericiguat, as a Phase III success last November. In 2016, Merck had paid $1 billion upfront for US rights to the Bayer-developed drug. Early projections foresaw a few hundred million a year in sales, but the unspecified late-stage success raised the possibility for far more. After all, Novartis’s flagship heart drug, Entresto, was earning $1.7 billion per year and was expected to reach up to $4 billion in annual sales.

GSK’s Shin­grix leader Guil­laume Pfe­fer has jumped on board Flag­ship to helm a biotech hy­brid as Afeyan’s lat­est CEO-part­ner

After spending 4 years in a senior post with GlaxoSmithKline’s star team positioning Shingrix for a blockbuster approval, Guillaume Pfefer is headed back to the biotech world — in style.

Pfefer has signed on to join Noubar Afeyan’s busy group of partners at Flagship, and he’s taking the helm of an upstart — which today is being merged with another Flagship startup — with some grand plans of its own. The announcement this morning notes that Pfefer will run Kintai Therapeutics, one of the grads of the Flagship labs.