For shame: ‘Phar­ma Bro’ Shkre­li is in prison, but Dara­prim’s price is still high

The move drew crit­i­cism from all cor­ners. Con­gress hauled Shkre­li in for ques­tion­ing on tele­vi­sion. Me­dia out­lets shamed the prac­tice. The Phar­ma­ceu­ti­cal Re­search and Man­u­fac­tur­ers of Amer­i­ca (PhRMA), the pow­er­ful trade group for brand­ed drugs, dis­tanced it­self, say­ing Tur­ing “does not rep­re­sent the val­ues of@PhRMA” and kicked off a cam­paign it de­scribed as “more lab coat, less hood­ie.”

Shkre­li, 35, is now serv­ing a sev­en-year prison term for se­cu­ri­ties fraud (un­re­lat­ed to Dara­prim). Tur­ing has re­named it­self Vy­era Phar­ma­ceu­ti­cals.

But Dara­prim, which costs pen­nies to make and is used to treat the par­a­sitic in­fec­tion tox­o­plas­mo­sis — which is rare in the Unit­ed States — still re­tails for more than $750 per pill, ac­cord­ing to drug web­site GoodRx.com. Vy­era did not re­spond to mul­ti­ple re­quests for com­ment.

The con­tin­ued high price of the drug is a cau­tion­ary tale to those who hope that pub­lic sham­ing of a few “bad ac­tors” can curb es­ca­lat­ing drug prices, be­cause the prob­lem is root­ed in the mar­ket’s un­der­ly­ing fi­nan­cial in­cen­tives.

Drug prices are “easy to raise and hard­er to low­er, par­tic­u­lar­ly if there’s no com­pe­ti­tion,” said Nichol­son Price, an as­sis­tant pro­fes­sor at the Uni­ver­si­ty of Michi­gan Law School. “The mys­tery isn’t, ‘Why don’t drug prices go down?’ It’s more, ‘Why don’t they go up more?’”

That’s es­pe­cial­ly the case with a prod­uct like Dara­prim, which ben­e­fits a rel­a­tive­ly small group of peo­ple — about 2,000 Amer­i­cans per year. That means less prof­it in­cen­tive for oth­er com­pa­nies to de­vel­op a com­peti­tor that could dri­ve down prices.

Joey Mat­ting­ly, an as­sis­tant pro­fes­sor at the Uni­ver­si­ty of Mary­land School of Phar­ma­cy, us­es Dara­prim as a case study in a uni­ver­si­ty course he teach­es on phar­ma­ceu­ti­cal busi­ness strat­e­gy, high­light­ing how the in­dus­try func­tions un­der cur­rent in­cen­tives.

“The mar­ket sort of sets it up where, if you need it, you have to pay for it,” he said. “A for-prof­it en­ti­ty is go­ing to raise the price.”

Brand­ed drugs like Dara­prim are more like­ly to be priced high with­out a clear jus­ti­fi­ca­tion, not­ed David Howard, a health econ­o­mist and pro­fes­sor at Emory Uni­ver­si­ty.

Dara­prim was first ap­proved by the Food and Drug Ad­min­is­tra­tion more than 50 years ago, and the patent has long since ex­pired for both the drug and its ac­tive in­gre­di­ent. But there’s no gener­ic equiv­a­lent in the Unit­ed States.

Even with gener­ic-drug com­pe­ti­tion, costs don’t al­ways drop. In 2015 alone, 300 gener­ic drugs — off-patent med­ica­tions, which are typ­i­cal­ly cheap to make — saw price in­creas­es of more than 100 per­cent, ac­cord­ing to a 2016 Gov­ern­ment Ac­count­abil­i­ty Of­fice re­port.

“We don’t have a good mod­el for pric­ing phar­ma­ceu­ti­cals in this coun­try and, as a re­sult, we keep spend­ing a lot more mon­ey,” Price said. “We avoid think­ing about it, or avoid deal­ing with it, and as a re­sult things get more prob­lem­at­ic.”

As prices climb, Vy­era has fol­lowed what has be­come a fa­mil­iar phar­ma­ceu­ti­cal play­book to shift at­ten­tion and costs, launch­ing what it calls the Dara­prim Di­rect pro­gram.

Com­mer­cial­ly in­sured pa­tients can get a com­pa­ny-spon­sored coupon that guar­an­tees they’ll pay no more than $10 out-of-pock­et. Unin­sured pa­tients at 500 per­cent or less of the fed­er­al pover­ty lev­el — about $82,300 for a fam­i­ly of two — won’t pay any­thing.

Peo­ple with Medicare Part D cov­er­age can ap­ply for co­pay as­sis­tance from an “in­de­pen­dent char­i­ta­ble foun­da­tion” to which Vy­era has do­nat­ed mon­ey. This op­tion is list­ed on the Dara­prim Di­rect web­site. Tech­ni­cal­ly, Medicare ben­e­fi­cia­ries can­not use com­pa­ny coupons, but many drug com­pa­nies skirt that reg­u­la­tion by send­ing as­sis­tance through a sep­a­rate in­ter­me­di­ary — such as an in­de­pen­dent char­i­ty. It’s com­mon enough that the prac­tice has re­cent­ly come un­der fed­er­al scruti­ny.

Crit­ics are quick to point out that such pro­grams — of­ten de­ployed for high-priced drugs — may en­able pa­tient ac­cess but do noth­ing to ad­dress over­all ex­pense. Pri­vate in­sur­ers, Medicare or Med­ic­aid must pay the tab, whether through in­creased pre­mi­ums or strained pub­lic health bud­gets.

On av­er­age, Med­ic­aid pro­grams in 2017 paid $35,556.48 per Dara­prim pre­scrip­tion, ac­cord­ing to a Kaiser Health News analy­sis of fed­er­al da­ta cov­er­ing that year’s first three quar­ters.

That fig­ure doesn’t ac­count for any re­bates state Med­ic­aid pro­grams like­ly re­ceive from Vy­era, which is undis­closed pro­pri­etary in­for­ma­tion. In Mass­a­chu­setts, those deals mean the state’s net costs for Dara­prim have re­mained large­ly un­changed since 2014, though the price tag is 75 times what it was, said a spokes­woman for the agency’s Ex­ec­u­tive Of­fice of Health and Hu­man Ser­vices.

But states have vari­able ne­go­ti­at­ing lever­age and skills in press­ing for dis­counts. And pay­ing for high-cost drugs — es­pe­cial­ly those with­out a com­peti­tor — re­mains a se­ri­ous chal­lenge, she said.

Gen­er­al­ly, Med­ic­aid like­ly pays hun­dreds of dol­lars per Dara­prim pill, said Matt Sa­lo, ex­ec­u­tive di­rec­tor of the Na­tion­al As­so­ci­a­tion of Med­ic­aid Di­rec­tors. A stan­dard start­ing dose of two to three pills per day lasts one to three weeks. And that’s like­ly to gen­er­ate costs much high­er than they were be­fore Shkre­li start­ed sell­ing Dara­prim.


By She­fali Luthra with con­tri­bu­tion from Syd­ney Lup­kin. Orig­i­nal­ly post­ed at Kaiser Health News, a na­tion­al health pol­i­cy news ser­vice that is part of the non­par­ti­san Hen­ry J Kaiser Fam­i­ly Foun­da­tion.

Note: To de­ter­mine what Med­ic­aid paid for Dara­prim, Kaiser Health News used da­ta made pub­lic by the Cen­ters for Medicare & Med­ic­aid Ser­vices. This fig­ure rep­re­sents a weight­ed av­er­age of Med­ic­aid pay­ments per pre­scrip­tion, across var­i­ous strengths, pack­age sizes, routes and la­bels. It does not in­clude drug ver­sions (rep­re­sent­ed by Na­tion­al Drug Codes) with few­er than 11 pre­scrip­tion fills per quar­ter.

A fa­vorite in Alex­ion’s C-suite is leav­ing, and some mighty sur­prised an­a­lysts aren’t the least bit hap­py about it

Analysts hate to lose a biotech CFO they’ve come to trust and admire — especially if they’re being blindsided by a surprise exit.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 59,900+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

David Grainger [file photo]

'Dis­con­nect the bas­tard­s' — one biotech's plan to break can­cer cell­s' uni­fied de­fens­es

Chemotherapy and radiotherapy are the current gladiators of cancer treatment, but they come with well-known limitations and side-effects. The emergence of immunotherapy — a ferocious new titan in oncologist’s toolbox — takes the brakes off the immune system to kill cancer cells with remarkable success in some cases, but the approach is not always effective. What makes certain forms of cancer so resilient? Scientists may have finally pieced together a tantalizing piece of the puzzle, and a new biotech is banking on a new approach to fill the gap.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 59,900+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

While No­var­tis ban­ish­es Zol­gens­ma scan­dal scars — Bio­gen goes on a Spin­raza 'of­fen­sive'

While Novartis painstakingly works to mop up the stench of the data manipulation scandal associated with its expensive gene therapy for spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) Zolgensma— rival Biogen is attempting to expand the use of its SMA therapy, Spinraza. 

The US drugmaker $BIIB secured US approval for Spinraza for use in the often fatal genetic disease in 2016. The approval covered a broad range of patients with infantile-onset (most likely to develop Type 1) SMA. 

Jason Kelly. Mike Blake/Reuters via Adobe

Eye­ing big ther­a­peu­tic push, Gink­go bags $290M to build a cell pro­gram­ming em­pire

Ginkgo Bioworks is on a roll. Days after publicizing a plan to nurture new startups via partnerships with accelerators Y Combinator and Petri, the Boston biotech says it has raised another $290 million for its cell programming platform to reach further and wider.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 59,900+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

UP­DAT­ED: Speak­er Nan­cy Pelosi to un­veil bill for fed­er­al­ly ne­go­ti­at­ed drug prices

After months of buzz from both sides of the aisle, Speaker Nancy Pelosi will today introduce her plan to allow the federal government to negotiate prices for 250 prescription drugs, setting up a showdown with a pharmaceutical industry working overtime to prevent it.

The need to limit drug prices is a rare point of agreement between President Trump and Democrats, although the president has yet to comment on the proposal and will likely face pressure to back a more conservative option or no bill at all. Republican Senator Chuck Grassley is reportedly lobbying his fellow party members on a more modest proposal he negotiated with Democratic Senator Ron Wyden in July.

Jeff Kindler's Cen­trex­ion re­news bid to make pub­lic de­but

Jeffrey Kindler’s plan to take his biotech — which is developing a slate of non-opioid painkillers — public, is back on.

The Boston based company, led by former Pfizer $PFE chief Kindler, originally contemplated a $70 million to $80 million IPO last year— but eventually postponed that strategy. On Wednesday, the company revived its bid to make a public debut in a filing with the SEC — although no pricing details were disclosed.

Zachary Hornby. Boundless

'A fourth rev­o­lu­tion in can­cer ther­a­pies': ARCH-backed Bound­less Bio flash­es big check, makes big­ger promis­es in de­but

It was the cellular equivalent of opening your car door and finding an active, roaring engine in the driver seat.

Scientists learned strands of DNA could occasionally appear outside of its traditional home in the nucleus in the 1970s, when they appeared as little, innocuous circles on microscopes; inexplicable but apparently innate. But not until UC San Diego’s Paul Mischel published his first study in Science in 2014 did researchers realize these circles were not only active but potentially overactive and driving some cancer tumors’ superhuman growth.

It’s fi­nal­ly over: Bio­gen, Ei­sai scrap big Alzheimer’s PhI­I­Is af­ter a pre­dictable BACE cat­a­stro­phe rais­es safe­ty fears

Months after analysts and investors called on Biogen and Eisai to scrap their BACE drug for Alzheimer’s and move on in the wake of a string of late-stage failures and rising safety fears, the partners have called it quits. And they said they were dropping the drug — elenbecestat — after the independent monitoring board raised concerns about…safety.

We don’t know exactly what researchers found in this latest catastrophe, but the companies noted in their release that investigators had determined that the drug was flunking the risk/benefit analysis.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 59,900+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Mer­ck helps bankroll new part­ner Themis' game plan to fin­ish the chikun­gun­ya race and be­gin on­colyt­ic virus quest

As Themis gears up for a Phase III trial of its chikungunya vaccine, the Vienna-based biotech has closed out €40 million ($44 million) to foot the clinical and manufacturing bills.

Its heavyweight partners at Merck — which signed a pact around a mysterious “blockbuster indication” last month — jumped into the Series D, led by new investors Farallon Capital and Hadean Ventures. Adjuvant Capital also joined, as did current investors Global Health Investment Fund, aws Gruenderfonds, Omnes Capital, Ventech and Wellington Partners Life Sciences.