It’s over: Eli Lil­ly shares tank af­ter its huge gam­ble on Alzheimer’s drug solanezum­ab ends in fail­ure

Eli Lil­ly CEO John Lech­leit­er

Eli Lil­ly’s mon­u­men­tal ef­fort to prove once and for all that solanezum­ab could work in de­lay­ing Alzheimer’s has end­ed in to­tal fail­ure. The phar­ma gi­ant an­nounced this morn­ing that the drug failed its third Phase III ef­fort at Lil­ly, send­ing its stock in­to a tail­spin.

Back in 2012, in­ves­ti­ga­tors for Lil­ly con­vinced the top ex­ecs at the com­pa­ny that they had seen re­al, tan­gi­ble ben­e­fits for ear­ly-stage pa­tients tak­ing the drug, de­signed to elim­i­nate de­posits of amy­loid be­ta in the brain. The da­ta, they felt, war­rant­ed an­oth­er clin­i­cal odyssey in Phase III, even though that study had failed. And CEO John Lech­leit­er was a stout ad­vo­cate through­out, will­ing to in­vest heav­i­ly in the study. But in the end, the drug of­fered noth­ing but false hope to mil­lions of pa­tients, fail­ing to bend the curve on cog­ni­tive de­clines or the abil­i­ty of pa­tients to func­tion bet­ter.

Lil­ly will take a mod­est $150 mil­lion charge in the fourth quar­ter — just a frac­tion of what it has spent on this drug.

Its shares plunged 14% on the news. And the dam­age ex­tend­ed to oth­er com­pa­nies pur­su­ing the amy­loid be­ta the­o­ry. Bio­gen, which has pro­mot­ed the prospect of ad­u­canum­ab, watched its stock plunge 10% in pre-mar­ket trad­ing. And Ax­o­vant, a com­pa­ny that nabbed a failed Alzheimer’s drug from GSK and put it back in­to the clin­ic, saw its shares drop 18%, even though their drug goes af­ter a com­plete­ly dif­fer­ent tar­get.

The fail­ure here casts a par­tic­u­lar pall over the amy­loid be­ta the­o­ry. The tox­ic pro­tein clus­ters in pa­tients’ brains are con­sid­ered the most like­ly sus­pect for trig­ger­ing the dis­ease, which af­flicts mil­lions. Mer­ck, Bio­gen, Lil­ly and oth­ers all have oth­er pro­grams in the pipeline that look at var­i­ous ways to re­duce the lev­el of amy­loid be­ta in the brain. And those pro­grams will con­tin­ue, along with the de­bate over what tar­gets should be used in fu­ture stud­ies.

Not­ed Leerink’s Sea­mus Fer­nan­dez:

This re­sult will no doubt cast a shad­ow over LLY’s Alzheimer’s Dis­ease (AD) pipeline port­fo­lio, which is heav­i­ly based on the be­ta amy­loid hy­poth­e­sis. Oth­er com­peti­tors’ pro­grams based on this hy­poth­e­sis will prob­a­bly con­tin­ue, but this will like­ly have neg­a­tive read-through on these re­sults in the short term.

The fail­ure at Eli Lil­ly al­so un­der­scores the dis­as­trous record that Alzheimer’s drugs over­all have had in the clin­ic for more than a decade, with a near-uni­ver­sal fail­ure rate. Eli Lil­ly has had one of the longest run­ning R&D ef­forts in Alzheimer’s, with some jaw-drop­ping set­backs along the way. It al­so tried to go af­ter Alzheimer’s with sema­gace­s­tat, on­ly to find that the drug ap­par­ent­ly in­creased the risk of the dis­ease. In­ves­ti­ga­tors and ex­ecs, though, have been steadi­ly lured on by the prospect of mega-block­buster sales, of­ten cru­el­ly tout­ing the po­ten­tial of a ther­a­py, on­ly to ad­mit fail­ure in the end.

“The re­sults of the solanezum­ab EX­PE­DI­TION3 tri­al were not what we had hoped for and we are dis­ap­point­ed for the mil­lions of peo­ple wait­ing for a po­ten­tial dis­ease-mod­i­fy­ing treat­ment for Alzheimer’s dis­ease,” said Lech­leit­er. “We will eval­u­ate the im­pact of these re­sults on the de­vel­op­ment plans for solanezum­ab and our oth­er Alzheimer’s pipeline as­sets.”

Martin Shkreli [via Getty]

Pris­on­er #87850-053 does not get to add drug de­vel­op­er to his list of cred­its

Just days after Retrophin shed its last ties to founder Martin Shkreli, the biotech is reporting that the lead drug he co-invented flopped in a pivotal trial. Fosmetpantotenate flunked both the primary and key secondary endpoints in a placebo-controlled trial for a rare disease called pantothenate kinase-associated neurodegeneration, or PKAN.

Endpoints News

Basic subscription required

Unlock this story instantly and join 58,000+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Hal Barron. GSK

GSK's Hal Bar­ron her­alds their sec­ond pos­i­tive PhI­II for cru­cial an­ti-BC­MA ther­a­py, point­ing to a push for quick OKs in a crowd­ed field

Hal Barron has his second positive round of Phase III data in hand for his anti-BCMA antibody drug conjugate belantamab mafodotin (GSK2857916). And GSK’s research chief says the data paves the way for their drive in search of an FDA approval for treating multiple myeloma. 

It’s hard to overestimate the importance of this drug for GSK, a cornerstone of Barron’s campaign to make a dramatic impact on the oncology market and provide some long-lost excitement for the pharma giant’s pipeline. They’re putting this BCMA program at the front of that charge — looking to lead a host of rivals all aimed at the same target.

UP­DAT­ED: An em­bold­ened As­traZeneca splurges $95M on a pri­or­i­ty re­view vouch­er. Where do they need the FDA to hus­tle up?

AstraZeneca is in a hurry.

We learned this morning that the pharma giant — not known as a big spender, until recently — forked over $95 million to get its hands on a priority review voucher from Sobi, otherwise known as Swedish Orphan Biovitrum.

That marks another step down on price for a PRV, which allows the holder to slash 4 months off of any FDA review time.

Endpoints News

Basic subscription required

Unlock this story instantly and join 58,000+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

We­bi­nar: Re­al World End­points — the brave new world com­ing in build­ing fran­chise ther­a­pies

Several biopharma companies have been working on expanding drug labels through the use of real world endpoints, combing through the data to find evidence of a drug’s efficacy for particular indications. But we’ve just begun. Real World Evidence is becoming an important part of every clinical development plan, in the soup-through-nuts approach used in building franchises.

I’ve recruited a panel of 3 top experts in the field — the first in a series of premium webinars — to look at the practical realities governing what can be done today, and where this is headed over the next few years, at the prodding of the FDA.

ZHEN SU — Merck Serono’s Senior Vice President and Global Head of Oncology
ELLIOTT LEVY — Amgen’s Senior Vice President of Global Development
CHRIS BOSHOFF — Pfizer Oncology’s Chief Development Officer

A premium subscription to Endpoints News is required to attend this webinar. Please upgrade to either an Insider or Enterprise plan for access. Already have Endpoints Premium? Please sign-in below. You can contact our Subscriptions team at help@endpointsnews.com with any issues.

Endpoints Premium

Premium subscription required

Unlock this article along with other benefits by subscribing to one of our paid plans.

Brian Kaspar. AveXis via Twitter

AveX­is sci­en­tif­ic founder fires back at No­var­tis CEO Vas Narasimhan, 'cat­e­gor­i­cal­ly de­nies any wrong­do­ing'

Brian Kaspar’s head was among the first to roll at Novartis after company execs became aware of the fact that manipulated data had been included in its application for Zolgensma, now the world’s most expensive therapy.

But in his first public response, the scientific founder at AveXis — acquired by Novartis for $8.7 billion — is firing back. And he says that not only was he not involved in any wrongdoing, he’s ready to defend his name as needed.

I reached out to Brian Kaspar after Novartis put out word that he and his brother Allen had been axed in mid-May, two months after the company became aware of the allegations related to manipulated data. His response came back through his attorneys.

Endpoints News

Basic subscription required

Unlock this story instantly and join 58,000+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Bob Smith, Pfizer

Pfiz­er is mak­ing a $500M state­ment to­day: Here’s how you be­come a lead play­er in the boom­ing gene ther­a­py sec­tor

Three years ago, Pfizer anted up $150 million in cash to buy Bamboo Therapeutics in Chapel Hill, NC as it cautiously stuck a toe in the small gene therapy pool of research and development.

Company execs followed up a year later with a $100 million expansion of the manufacturing operations they picked up in that deal for the UNC spinout, which came with $495 million in milestones.

And now they’re really going for it.

Endpoints News

Basic subscription required

Unlock this story instantly and join 58,000+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Video: Putting the AI in R&D — with Badhri Srini­vasan, Tony Wood, Rosana Kapeller, Hugo Ceule­mans, Saurabh Sa­ha and Shoibal Dat­ta

During BIO this year, I had a chance to moderate a panel among some of the top tech experts in biopharma on their real-world use of artificial intelligence in R&D. There’s been a lot said about the potential of AI, but I wanted to explore more about what some of the larger players are actually doing with this technology today, and how they see it advancing in the future. It was a fascinating exchange, which you can see here. The transcript has been edited for brevity and clarity. — John Carroll

Am­gen, Al­ler­gan biosim­i­lar of Roche's block­buster Rit­ux­an clears an­oth­er US piv­otal study 

Novartis $NVS may have given up, but Amgen $AMGN and Allergan $AGN are plowing ahead with their knockoff of Roche’s blockbuster biologic Rituxan in the United States.

Their copycat, ABP 798, was found to have a clinically equivalent impact as Rituxan — meeting the main goal of the study involving CD20-positive B-cell non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma patients. This is the second trial supporting the profile of the biosimilar. In January, it came through with positive PK results in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.

BeiGene and Mus­tang nail down spe­cial FDA sta­tus for top drugs; Roche bags added cov­er­age for Hem­li­bra

→ BeiGene $BGNE is getting a boost in its drive to field a rival to Imbruvica. The FDA has offered an accelerated review to zanubrutinib, a BTK inhibitor that has posted positive results for mantle cell lymphoma. The PDUFA date lands on February 27, 2020. The drug scored breakthrough status at the beginning of the year.

→ BeiGene isn’t the only biopharma company to gain special regulatory status today. Mustang Bio $MBIO and St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital announced that MB-107, a lentiviral gene therapy for the treatment of X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency, also known as bubble boy disease, has been granted Regenerative Medicine Advanced Therapy status.