M&A in­fla­tion just pushed the av­er­age bio­phar­ma val­u­a­tion to a scary new peak

John Roun­tree

The con­sul­tants at No­va­sec­ta have been crunch­ing the num­bers on bio­phar­ma M&A for the past few years and con­clud­ed that a lot more of these deals are weigh­ing in so heav­i­ly in­flat­ed now that many buy­ers would be bet­ter off look­ing for oth­er ways to grow their busi­ness­es and their pipelines.

Look­ing at each deal as a mul­ti­ple of rev­enue for the ac­quired com­pa­ny, the Lon­don-based con­sul­tan­cy says that the me­di­an val­ue of a buy­out last year was 39 times rev­enue. Com­pare that to a me­di­an 19 times rev­enue in 2015 and 8 times rev­enue in 2014, and you get a point­ed pic­ture of the fresh peak that’s been cre­at­ed in val­u­a­tions.

Ze­ro­ing in on the amount paid rel­a­tive to sales rev­enue was a good proxy for rep­re­sent­ing the in­creas­ing amount that com­pa­nies are pay­ing for all their new as­sets, both on the mar­ket or still in the clin­ic. In an email ex­change, No­va­sec­ta Man­ag­ing Part­ner John Roun­tree tells me:

•The mul­ti­ple com­bine the two things go­ing on in M&A, one is the amount you have to pay to ac­quire a cer­tain amount of rev­enue, which is clear­ly up, and the sec­ond is that when rev­enue is low­er (i.e. most­ly pipeline val­ue) you are tak­ing more risk and bet­ting on the hope that your ac­qui­si­tion will pay off.

•To get a good-sized sam­ple and long-term trend we al­so looked at two co­horts of deal-mak­ing – 2009–2011 and 2014-2016 (five years lat­er).  This part of our analy­sis clear­ly shows that the mul­ti­ples are up across the board, so even when the com­pa­ny is not tak­ing on the risk of ear­ly-stage hope, they are al­so pay­ing much more for on-mar­ket rev­enue.

•So we don’t ex­plic­it­ly val­ue the ear­ly-stage pro­grams, this is in the eye of the be­hold­er, the is­sue is that ac­quir­ers are pay­ing more than they used to for ear­ly-stage gen­er­al­ly across the board.

That as­sess­ment may al­so help ex­plain why 2016 fell far short of over­all M&A ex­pec­ta­tions, as some com­pa­nies you’d ex­pect to be in the buy­er col­umn — hel­lo, Gilead — have steered clear of ac­qui­si­tions.

Any­one look­ing for spe­cif­ic ex­am­ples of how this trend is play­ing out in par­tic­u­lar deals need on­ly look at Al­ler­gan’s buy­out of To­bi­ra or Pfiz­er’s $14 bil­lion Medi­va­tion ac­qui­si­tion, which in­clud­ed a big share of a mar­ket­ed drug as well as a promi­nent ex­per­i­men­tal med. J&J’s prospec­tive ac­qui­si­tion of Acte­lion will do noth­ing to pop this par­tic­u­lar bub­ble.

“The bot­tom line is that the era of cheap cap­i­tal since 2008 has led to a sig­nif­i­cant in­fla­tion in deal val­ues across the board,” Roun­tree adds, “which can be great for the ac­quired com­pa­ny share­hold­ers but ques­tion­able for the ac­quir­er’s share­hold­ers.

“Our con­clu­sion is that though some deals will end up be­ing great for both par­ties, many are at over-in­flat­ed prices, and the ac­quir­ing com­pa­nies would do bet­ter to fo­cus on fix­ing their own shops and en­ter­ing in­to part­ner­ships where they need ex­tra ca­pa­bil­i­ty rather than ex­pen­sive M&A.”

Don’t look for the end of this trend in 2017 as Big Phar­ma waits for Pres­i­dent-elect Don­ald Trump to fol­low through with a high­ly an­tic­i­pat­ed move to al­low the multi­na­tion­als to repa­tri­ate bil­lions in over­seas cash.

“Our sense is that 2017 is un­like­ly to see a de­crease in the prices paid, per­haps they will go high­er yet: there is a lot of mon­ey in the ecosys­tem seek­ing the high re­turns that suc­cess­ful in­no­va­tion can cre­ate,” notes Roun­tree. “The price of rev­enue-gen­er­at­ing deals will be­come pro­hib­i­tive due to lack of sup­ply, ex­cept for those with ex­treme­ly strong bal­ance sheets or very pa­tient share­hold­ers or both.”

5AM Ven­tures: Fu­el­ing the Next Gen­er­a­tion of In­no­va­tors

By RBC Capital Markets
With Andy Schwab, Co-Founder and Managing Partner at 5AM Ventures

Key Points

Prescription Digital Therapeutics, cell therapy technologies, and in silico medicines will be a vital part of future treatment modalities.
Unlocking the potential of the microbiome could be the missing link to better disease diagnosis.
Growing links between academia, industry, and venture capital are spinning out more innovative biotech companies.
Biotech is now seen by investors as a growth space as well as a safe haven, fuelling the recent IPO boom.

Biohaven CEO Vlad Coric (Photo Credit: Andrew Venditti)

Pssst: That big Bio­haven Alzheimer's study? It was a bust. Even the sub­group analy­sis ex­ecs tout­ed was a flop

You know it’s bad when a biopharma player plucks out a subgroup analysis for a positive take — even though it was way off the statistical mark for success, like everything else.

So it was for Biohaven $BHVN on MLK Monday, as the biotech reported on the holiday that their Phase II/III Alzheimer’s study for troriluzole flunked both co-primary endpoints as well as a key biomarker analysis.

The drug — a revised version of the ALS drug riluzole designed to regulate glutamate — did not “statistically differentiate” from placebo on the Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale-Cognitive Subscale 11 (ADAS-cog) and the Clinical Dementia Rating Scale Sum of Boxes (CDR-SB).  The “hippocampal volume” assessment by MRI also failed to distinguish itself from placebo for all patients fitting the mild-to-moderate disease profile they had established for the study.

Endpoints Premium

Premium subscription required

Unlock this article along with other benefits by subscribing to one of our paid plans.

Andrew Allen, Gritstone CEO (Gritstone via website)

Grit­stone con­tin­ues Covid-19 push with deal to de­vel­op 'self-am­pli­fy­ing RNA' vac­cines, as shares con­tin­ue bal­loon­ing

Gritstone Oncology has had a big week, and it’s only Wednesday.

On Tuesday, the biotech revealed plans to start clinical testing of an experimental Covid-19 vaccine — in tandem with NIAID — that can also target other coronaviruses, with the goal of preventing future pandemics should SARS-CoV-2 prove difficult to cure with current vaccines. Then, on Wednesday morning, Gritstone licensed lipid nanoparticle technology from Genevant Sciences to develop what it’s calling “self-amplifying RNA vaccines” against Covid-19.

Artist rendering of the Assembly Square site in Somerville, MA (BioMed Realty)

Bio­Med Re­al­ty snaps up in­no­va­tion cam­pus site with­in earshot of pricey and bustling Boston biotech hub

On the short list of the premier biotech hubs in the world, the Boston area has transformed into a home for innovation — and ridiculously high rent. Now, a real estate firm is seeking tenants for a major site in neighboring Somerville with more than enough elbow room.

Snapped up by BioMed Realty, the land — which consists of an existing 162,000 square-foot office building and a 7.5 acre site — will serve as an “innovation space” for a variety of research, technology and life science tenants, the real estate company said in a press release. Financial terms weren’t disclosed.

FDA hits the brakes on His­to­gen's knee car­ti­lage ther­a­py, ask­ing for more in­fo on man­u­fac­tur­ing process

A month after filing the IND application for its human extracellular matrix designed to regenerate knee cartilage, Histogen has hit a roadblock.

The FDA on Tuesday verbally notified the San Diego-based biotech that it was placing a clinical hold on the planned Phase I/II clinical trial of HST-003 due to pending CMC information and additional questions needed to complete their review.

Histogen had planned to test the safety and efficacy of implanting hECM within microfracture interstices and related cartilage defects to regenerate that cartilage in conjunction with a microfracture procedure. The company said in a press release that it expects to receive written notice of the clinical hold from the FDA by Feb 12.

Hal Barron, GSK R&D chief (GSK via YouTube)

Glax­o­SmithK­line's $4B bis­pe­cif­ic can­cer drug al­liance with Mer­ck KGaA hit by big set­back with a PhI­II fail­ure on NSCLC

Close to 2 years ago, GSK’s R&D team eagerly agreed to pay up to $4 billion-plus to ally itself with Merck KGaA on a mid-stage bispecific called bintrafusp alfa, which intrigued them with the combination of a TGF-β trap with the anti-PD-L1 mechanism in one fusion protein.

But today the German pharma company says that their lead study on lung cancer was a bust, as independent monitors said there was no reason to believe that the experimental drug — targeting PD-L1/TGF-Beta — could beat Keytruda.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 98,200+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Sanofi protests, AP Images

Paul Hud­son faces down French unions in fight to re­struc­ture Sanofi

Sanofi CEO Paul Hudson is facing a familiar adversary in his efforts to cut up to 1,680 jobs from the French pharma giant: French unions.

Around 200 union members staged a one-day strike Tuesday at Sanofi’s main Covid-19 vaccine plant in Marcy-l’Étoile to protest the cuts, The Associated Press reported, with other members joining at other facilities across the country.

France’s finance minister Bruno Le Maire, meanwhile, went on French radio twice this week to talk about the company. On Monday, per Reuters, he told RTL that Sanofi would not close any plants or lay off any employees in the restructuring. But on Wednesday morning, he re-emerged on BFM and said he would like three things from the drugmaker, including confirmation that there will be no site closures and layoffs.

Janet Woodcock and Joshua Sharfstein (AP, Images)

Poll: Should Joshua Sharf­stein or Janet Wood­cock lead the FDA from here?

It’s time for a new FDA commissioner to come on board, a rite of passage for Joe Biden’s administration that should help seal the new president’s rep on seeking out the experts to lead the government over the next 4 years.

As of now, the competition for the top job appears to have narrowed down to 2 people: The longtime CDER chief Janet Woodcock and Joshua Sharfstein, the former principal deputy at the FDA under Peggy Hamburg. Both were appointed by Barack Obama.

Bris­tol My­ers Squibb gets re­view date for Op­di­vo com­bo in gas­tric can­cer, look­ing to over­turn Keytru­da's 3-year lead

The past two months have been tough for Bristol Myers Squibb and its checkpoint inhibitor Opdivo after setbacks in lung and brain cancers. But in the battle against Merck’s Keytruda, any success matters — and now Bristol could be looking at a quick approval for Opdivo in an unmatched indication.

The FDA will launch a speedy review of a combination of Bristol Myers Squibb’s Opdivo and chemotherapy to treat first-line patients with advanced or metastatic gastric cancer, gastroesophageal junction cancer or esophageal adenocarcinoma, the drugmaker said Wednesday. The agency set an action date of May 25 for the application.