Much crit­i­cized Mallinck­rodt bows out of PhRMA ahead of some tight­ened re­stric­tions on mem­ber­ship

Mark Tyn­dall, Mallinck­rodt

Just ahead of some new, more mus­cu­lar rules gov­ern­ing who can be a part of the in­dus­try lob­by­ing or­ga­ni­za­tion PhRMA, one of its most heav­i­ly crit­i­cized mem­bers is pulling out.

PhRMA con­firmed to me Wednes­day af­ter­noon that Mallinck­rodt — at the cen­ter of a lin­ger­ing drug pric­ing scan­dal — has re­signed from the trade group.

Just a few months ago, Mallinck­rodt agreed to pay a $100 mil­lion fine to re­solve a probe of the long, rather sor­did his­to­ry be­hind Ac­thar, an in­fan­tile spasm drug which cost $28,000 a vial when Mallinck­rodt picked it up in the $5.6 bil­lion ac­qui­si­tion of Quest­cor. Quest­cor had been jack­ing up the price on Ac­thar when it paid No­var­tis $135 mil­lion to gain US rights to a ther­a­py that posed a di­rect threat to its drug fran­chise. And Mallinck­rodt was forced to pay the fine for il­le­gal­ly main­tain­ing a drug mo­nop­oly — not the kind of sanc­tion PhRMA likes to see for mem­bers.

To­day, a lit­tle more than two years lat­er, the FTC says Ac­thar costs $34,000 a vial. Over 15 years the price on Ac­thar has gone up 85,000%. Mallinck­rodt earned $1.16 bil­lion on Ac­thar last year, when it spent a to­tal of $262 mil­lion on R&D, 7.7% of its net rev­enue of $3.4 bil­lion.

This was all play­ing out when Marathon Phar­ma­ceu­ti­cals grabbed an FDA ap­proval for an old steroid, de­flaza­cort, specif­i­cal­ly for Duchenne mus­cu­lar dy­s­tro­phy and priced the ther­a­py — avail­able from UK sources at around $1,000 a year — at $89,000. Marathon CEO Jeff Aronin, who still sits on PhRMA’s board, ducked low when a con­tro­ver­sy burst out over the price as well as ques­tion­able claims about what it spent on re­search­ing the steroid and lat­er sold de­flaza­cort to PTC Ther­a­peu­tics for $140 mil­lion, plus a roy­al­ty stream and a po­ten­tial $50 mil­lion mile­stone.

Stephen Ubl, PhRMA CEO

PhRMA, mean­while, was rolling out a mul­ti­mil­lion dol­lar ad cam­paign aimed at im­prov­ing pub­lic opin­ion about drug­mak­ers. The pub­lic has reg­is­tered on­ly no­to­ri­ous­ly low sup­port for phar­ma com­pa­nies over­all. The group launched a re­view of its mem­ber­ship rules, sug­gest­ing that Marathon and oth­ers might not stay mem­bers once they tight­ened the cri­te­ria for join­ing, clear­ly pre­fer­ring to stick with big play­ers who tra­di­tion­al­ly in­vest heav­i­ly in R&D.

For Mallinck­rodt’s part, the de­par­ture was rou­tine and am­i­ca­ble. A spokesper­son tells me:

Mallinck­rodt rou­tine­ly eval­u­ates its en­gage­ment in trade as­so­ci­a­tions and pol­i­cy or­ga­ni­za­tions and has con­clud­ed that the sig­nif­i­cant fi­nan­cial and time com­mit­ment re­quired as a full PhRMA mem­ber out­weighs its di­rect pol­i­cy val­ue to us at this time, giv­en our present size and staff foot­print. We con­tin­ue to sub­scribe to the PhRMA Code of Con­duct, sup­port many of the group’s po­si­tions and ini­tia­tives and look for­ward to con­tin­u­ing our pos­i­tive work­ing re­la­tion­ship with PhRMA and its mem­bers.

Mallinck­rodt was singing a dif­fer­ent tune when they joined in ear­ly 2015.

“We are proud to be sit­ting at the same ta­ble as most of the top in­no­v­a­tive phar­ma­ceu­ti­cal com­pa­nies in the world, which puts us in a po­si­tion to help shape our in­dus­try in a way that sup­ports pa­tients and providers for the com­ing decades,” said Mark Tyn­dall, Vice Pres­i­dent of Gov­ern­ment Af­fairs, Pol­i­cy and Ad­vo­ca­cy, at the time.

Un­lock­ing ESG strate­gies for growth with Gilead Sci­ences

RBC Capital Markets explores what is material in ESG for biopharma companies with the ESG leads at Gilead Sciences. Gilead has long focused on sustainability but recognized a more robust framework was needed. Based on a materiality assessment, Gilead’s ESG strategy today focuses first on drug access and pricing, while also addressing D&I and climate change. Find out why Gilead’s board is “acutely aware” of the contribution that ESG makes to firm’s overall success.

What con­tro­ver­sy? Eli Lil­ly plots Alzheimer's BLA fil­ing lat­er this year as FDA taps more an­ti-amy­loid drugs as break­throughs

The FDA is keeping the good news coming for Alzheimer’s drug developers. And Eli Lilly is taking them up on it.

Amid continued controversy around whether Biogen’s new flagship drug, Aduhelm, should have been approved at all — and swelling, heated debates surrounding its $56,000 price tag — the agency had no issue handing them and their Japanese partner Eisai a breakthrough therapy designation for a second anti-amyloid beta antibody, lecanemab, late Wednesday.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 110,100+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

New FDA doc­u­ments show in­ter­nal dis­sent on Aduhelm ap­proval

In a lengthy review document and a pair of memos from top officials, the FDA released on Tuesday night its most detailed argument yet for approving Biogen’s intensely controversial Alzheimer’s drug aducanumab.

The documents amount to an agency attempt to quench the firestorm their decision kindled, as outside advisors members resigned and experts warned that an unproven drug now could stretch Medicare’s budget to a breaking point. Ultimately, the documents show how CDER director Patrizia Cavazzoni and Office of New Drugs director Peter Stein both concurred with FDA neuroscience head Billy Dunn on the accelerated approval while the staff at FDA’s Office of Biostatistics did not think an approval was warranted.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 110,100+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Hervé Hoppenot, Incyte CEO (Jeff Rumans)

ODAC echoes FDA con­cern over In­cyte PD-1, as Paz­dur sig­nals broad­er shift for ac­cel­er­at­ed ap­proval

After the FDA lambasted their PD-1 ahead of an adcomm earlier this week, Incyte ran into new trouble Thursday as ODAC panelists voted against an accelerated OK by a wide margin.

Members of the Oncologic Drugs Advisory Committee recommended with a 13-4 vote to defer a regulatory decision on Incyte’s retifanlimab until after more data can be collected from a placebo-controlled trial. The PD-1 therapy is due for a PDUFA date in late July after receiving priority review earlier this year.

Karen Flynn, Catalent

Q&A: When the pan­dem­ic struck, Catal­en­t's CCO had just joined the team

Karen Flynn came aboard Catalent’s team just in time.

The company was going through a surge of changes, and she had been brought over from her role as CCO of West Pharmaceutical Services to serve in the same capacity for the New Jersey-based CDMO. Then a few months later, the pandemic was in full-force.

Since then, Catalent’s been in hyper-expansion mode. In early May, it acquired Promethera’s Hepatic Cell Therapy Support SA subsidiary and its 32,40-square-foot facility in Gosselies, Belgium. Prior to that, the company acquired Belgian CDMO Delphi Genetics, wrapped up the expansion of an already-existing site in Madison, WI and added an ultra-low temperature freezer partner in Sterling. As Emergent has botched millions of doses of AstraZeneca’s vaccine, the company has swooped in to move that production to its Maryland plant as well.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 110,100+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

Richard Pazdur (vis AACR)

FDA en­cour­ages in­clud­ing in­cur­able can­cer pa­tients in tri­als, re­gard­less of pri­or ther­a­pies

The FDA on Thursday called to include those with incurable cancers (when there is no potential for cure or for prolonged/near normal survival) in appropriate clinical trials, regardless of whether they have received existing alternative treatments.

Historically, many cancer clinical trials have required that participating patients previously received multiple therapies, according to Richard Pazdur, director of the FDA’s Oncology Center of Excellence.

On heels of Aduhelm ap­proval, Bris­tol My­ers jumps back in­to Alzheimer's race

Bristol Myers Squibb last put major resources behind an Alzheimer’s drug nearly a decade ago, when their own attempt at targeting amyloid flamed out in mid-stage studies. They invented another molecule, a Tau-targeted antibody, but jettisoned it to Biogen in 2017 as they dropped out of neuroscience altogether.

But on Thursday, the New York pharma announced they were getting back in the game. Bristol Myers exercised an $80 million option to bring a tau-targeted antibody from Prothena into a Phase I study. The opt-in, which Bristol Myers triggered ahead of analyst expectations, opens the door for another $1.7 billion in milestones down the road.

Endpoints News

Keep reading Endpoints with a free subscription

Unlock this story instantly and join 110,100+ biopharma pros reading Endpoints daily — and it's free.

James Peyer, Cambrian

Can a cell ther­a­py treat mus­cu­lar dy­s­tro­phy? A Ger­man bil­lion­aire's an­ti-ag­ing start­up is try­ing to find out

Gene therapy companies have faced huge hurdles trying to deliver healthy genes into muscular dystrophy patients’ muscle cells, so here’s an idea: Why don’t we just replace the muscle cells themselves?

Over the last two years, Vita Therapeutics has been exploring that possibility, building on early stem cell work from Johns Hopkins professor Peter Andersen. And on Tuesday they announced a $32 million Series A to begin to move their first therapy into the clinic, where they hope it will help rebuild muscle in patients with a type of dystrophy that afflicts the arms and legs.

Emma Walmsley (GSK via investor day livestream)

Mul­ti­va­lent mR­NA vac­cines, I/O 3.0, long-act­ing HIV drugs: The $46B game is on for the new Glax­o­SmithK­line

To understand the new GlaxoSmithKline that Emma Walmsley is promising to usher in, one must see through the old GSK.

“We know this has been a company that has perennially disappointed when you look at the first half of the last decade,” the CEO said in one of her final remarks at the long-anticipated investor day.

But after four years of strategic transformation and investment, her top team is ready to take the wraps off a shiny new version of the Big Pharma that, among other things, will strive to deliver £33 billion ($46 billion) in annual sales by 2031. It will start with a planned demerger of the consumer health business into a separate company in the middle of next year, while the new GSK retains a 20% stake as a “short-term financial investment.”